Rank these dmen. Points Only!
 

Looking to pickup a dman. My current team is in my signature. I just made a trade and I'm short a dman. Please rank points only.

Salo
Hamhuis
Tyutin
Gilbert
Kostka
Diaz
Souray
Redden
Bogosian (injured)
Kaberle

Thanks Guys

Souray
...
...
...
...

I like your style.... I currently have Souray and Kaberle on my team. I think I need to drop Kaberle for a different dman option and keep Souray. I just wanted them in the rankings to see if I should be possibly dropping both.. Looks like i'll be keeping Souray..

I guess in the end would you drop Kaberle for any of the above dmen (excluding Souray)?

Well, we know he's going to get injured any day now...but it's hard to go against Sami Salo when he's getting 24mins a night and top PP time in TBay.

If its for your last DMan, that seems to be an okay pickup.

My top 4 were.(if i kept Souray).

Salo
Hamhuis
Diaz
Gilbert

Salo
Souray
Hamhuis
Gilbert

Bogosian would be my favourite when he's ready to play.

1. Souray
2. Diaz
3. Hamhuis
4. Tyutin
5. Gilbert
6. Salo
7. Redden
8. Kostka
9. Kaberle

I'll go:

Bogo
Souray
Diaz
Salo
Kaberle
Redden
Hamhuis
Gilbert
Kotska
Tyutin

As a Salo owner, I know I'd take Souray for him straight up without thinking.

I'm surprised to see him atop some lists.

Souray
Diaz
Bogosian
Salo
Gilbert
Tyutin
Gilbert
Kaberle
Redden
Hamhuis
Kostka