My Silverberg and Hamilton for Wheeler and Diaz
 

Keeper League. Points only. Need to drop 9 players at end of the year. I know it is early in the season but I am a contending team and have a good shot at winning this year. Would you guys do this deal or even consider moving either of my 2 rookies for a player comparable to a Wheeler or would you ask for more?

No. I would not do this deal even if you are contending.

wheeler and diaz are hardly players you trade for while contending they are the types of players you unload to bring in players to contend with

Not like you need another voice in this but I'm w/ V-O-A and Louis-316.

Add me to the list of of those advocating against this move. I know its early, but Silfverberg could come within 80% of Wheeler's production in my mind.

The suggestion of this one baffles me completely. Unless you're in a position where you'd have to drop Silf and Hamilton for nothing some time soon, don't do it.

Keep your dudes!! Much better chance with them..unless Hamilton gets sent down after 5 games..

Run away, Run away fast. Silf and Hamilton are in the NHL to stay and their combined potential is significantly greater than Diaz and Wheeler. In a one year league, I would likely not do this deal , in a keeper, absolutely not.

Silfverberg has started slow for sure, but he will get his chances and once they start goin in expect his confidence to grow and the points will come. Hamilton is looking like a beast in the making.

no way i do this deal.

Thanks everyone!

I think I already knew the answer to this one but was starting to doubt myself for some reason. This forum is awesome! Keep up the great work all!!!