Should I drop P.K. Subban or Phaneuf for Ehroff?
 

I feel like Karlsson and Byfuglien are too much of an asset to ever get rid of. But I don't see enough potential in Phaneuf and Subban seems to be a wasted bench space, will he really be worth it?

The replacement I'm looking at is Ehroff who's a free agent, seems like the Sabres will be pulling in a lot of points for him. Was also considering Wideman.

The league has 7 teams and is one year only with a simple point system of goals and assists worth 1 point and we only get 3 free agent pick ups so I want them to count

Forwards: Tavares, Spezza, Hartnell, Nash, Kane, M Koivu, Pavelski, Jagr
Defence: Karlsson, Byfuglien, Phaneuf
Goaltender: Rinne
Bench: Selanne, P.K. Subban, Brodeur

3 games is not enough of a time frame to conclude that Ehrhoff will out-point Subban and Phaneuf. I wouldn't do it. Save the FA pickups.

Btw in the future, you may wish to pose your questions in the "one year league" board....keeper leagues have different considerations.

Anyway...give it a few more games.

Totally agree! I would add that history does not justify "Ehrhoff will out-point Subban and Phaneuf"

no. i wouldnt.

Should I slam my ***** in a door? Should I have unprotected sex in Haiti? Should I wear skinny jeans at 40 years old? Those questions all have the same value as the one proposed.

Seriously dude, there's no need to belittle someone like that. I'm going to assume you wrote that without thinking, and you didn't mean to be such a prick.

I wasn't berating anyone. It was a joke. My apologies if it came across wrong

lmao it got the point across well!

Also I dropped PK for Tarasenko of all people in the end

I guess I overreacted. My apologies to Mormerod.

And I was going to say yes you should to all of your questions :) lol

Skinny jeans at 40, that's grounds for a hanging right there ;)

To the op, you dropped PK and picked up Tarasenko !!!!! How in the world was he still available in your league. I know it's only 7 teams but I seriously would have thought someone would have picked him up.