Stamkos, Ovechkin or Seguin +
 

Points-only, which do you like most?

Feel free to expand on the reasons for your vote --or give me your ranking.

Edit: Please see my posts at 9 and 12.

I think Stamkos' three consecutive 90+ point seasons speak for themselves. Meanwhile Ovechkin has regressed a lot.

Although I do like Ovi for a bounce back season, I would take Stamkos here

Stamkos!!! Stamkos will give you 50-60 goals and 95-100pts for the next 10 years.

Stamkos has proven that he can do it year after year (90+ pts 3 years in a row). Until Ovie shows that he can turn it around I would take Stamkos all the way in a pts only league.

I voted... and in the majority.
Currently 10-1-1 for Stamkos.

This year. Stammer, Ove, Seguin. Years beyond, Stammer, Seguin and Ove.

Took Ove with my 1st rd pick in my office pool last night (7th overall pick). Think he rebounds this year. Seguin went quite early too.

Yep to the yep.

Excellent guys, thanks for all the replies (and feel free to keep 'em coming).

This sort of confirms my own thinking so far.

I've just offered my Seguin and Strome for his Stamkos. Somewhat to my surprise, the Stamkos owner is intrigued and is considering. I think that'd be a pretty decent move if I can actually pull it off. (I fully expect to be a contender this year)

I've had pretty strong signals from the Ovechkin owner that he'd likely make the same deal (i.e. his OV for my Seguin and Strome), but I just can't bring myself to pulling the trigger on that one.

1. Stamkos
2. Ovechkin
3. Seguin and Strome