Holtby vs. Neuvirth vs. Bobrovsky
 

Which one would you take in a head to head league where the stats are GS, W, L, Goals Against, GAA, SV%, Saves, Minutes Played, Shutout?

I'd handcuff both Holtby and Neuvirth. Would not consider Bob

Another team has Holtby. I was thinking about grabbing Neuvirth. My goalies are currently Quick and Pavelec but running with 3 goalies with those stats should really help me. Chances Neuvirth plays more then Holtby?

I go with Holtby if that's an option.

Who do you guys think is WSH starter? Holtby or Neuvirth? Has to be Holtby after the playoffs?

I think most goalie timeshares are risky as hell. Wins are gonna be so much more important than a regular season. Teams can't afford to let their goalie work out of a cold streak. STL, WSH, OTT, EDM, FLA, and TB all hvae very risky goalie situations and its a toss up as to who will start more games since they don't have a clear number 1 (add in VAN if Luongo doesn't get traded I just think he will).

Not necessarily. Goalies get hot in the playoffs all the time. Holtby still only played 6 games outside of the playoffs. Look at the Halak situation (only one that comes to mind right now, but I know there are others). It's hard to bank on a hot streak from a goalie in the playoffs.

I think they will fight it out and Holtby will win.

Holtby is the best option for me, I think he's the best goalie of the group, and it's pretty obvious to think that the Capitals will be a better team than the Blue Jackets. Holtby will obviously be battling for starts with his teammate Neuvirth, but I feel like Holtby is better and thus will take the majority of the starts. While Bobrovsky might get more starts than either one of the Capitals goalies, I don't like him as much as Holtby, as I'm not very comfortable with the team in front of him, talent wise I wouldn't put him above Holtby either.

For me Holtby is the best choice of the group. Number two could go either way, I think Neuvirth is safer than Bobrovsky, but I'd rather go for a homerun swing and take Bob over Neuvirth, as this is a small risk with the reward being greater than the risk.