Which of these D-men do I keep?
 

Michael Del Zotto
Cam Fowler
Christian Ehrhoff
Andrei Markov
Dennis Wideman

I was planning on keeping Fowler, but now I'm that maybe MDZ, or even one of the others may be a better choice. I've had Fowler for 2 seasons now and passed up numerous offers that were pretty decent for him, so its hard to let him go. However, I don't want my judgment to be clouded by those facts, and really need to just pick the best player.

What do you guys think?

How many do you keep?

Sorry, didn't make that clear.

Of those listed, I'm keeping one.

Its between MDZ and Fowler for me....and I lean just slightly towards MDZ.

MDZ for me, should have the +/- advantage for a long time over Fowler. MDZ is marginally better in the PIM department. Shots should be pretty close, with slight edge to Fowler.

In points both of them should be fairly close, depends on how there teams do. Both guys as it stands are the top D on there team for the PP.

I think the +/- is the thing that puts it in MDZ's favour.