Pietrangelo for Voracek
 

Points only (G=1. A=1) limited keeper salary cap league (8F,3D, G). Who would you rather own

As much as I like Pie his salary might become too burdensome to be a keeper. Also seems like D are somewhat undervalued based on your keeper system. Not happy about it but Voracek might be the better option and then you just gotta hope he goes for 60+.

What's the roster look like currently?

Pietrangelo by a wide margin.

I second this!

what he said... if you only start 8 fwds and voracek falls short of expectations then ww may have guys almost equivalent out there. pietrangelo is a top 75 contributor in almost any set up, as a high scoring young dman not many other then karlsson letang or weber intrigue me as much.

Pietrangelo easily. Even if you will only be able to use one year of Pietroangelo's service due to salary this deal is more than worth it.

Pietrangelo is an elite player at his position, Voracek is not. In a league where you only ice 8 forwards and 3 D, I would defiantly want as high end talent as possible on my back end.

The cap goes down to 65M next year so this is the best time for one of your stars to hit free agency. It's going to be an awkward fit for a year or two given that teams operated under a 70.2 million ceiling this summer. I can see some of the star players signing short deals and wait for the dust to settle before signing a longer deal.

I know the Blues are not a cap ceiling team and will have the space for Pietrangelo but the market has changed a lot.

Pietrangelo for me.

I agree 100%