He asked for my Yandle
 

Him: Would you trade Yandle to me before the draft?
Me: Yes.
Him: Who do you want from my team?
Me: OK, let's keep Ovechkin out of the deal. So, the player I want is Getzlaf.
Him: No. Chose another one.
Me: So I'll keep Yandle.

Looking at his team, he will probably keep 5 forwards and 1 goalie.
Ovechkin, Getzlaf, St.Louis, Zetterberg, Eriksson, Lundqvist.

Would you come back to him with another offer? If yes, wich?
Am I better to keep my team as in my signature (keep 3F + 2D + 1G) or trade Yandle for St.Louis and go the 4F + 1D + 1G way with the TB duo?
I'm afraid that Yandle's value will only go up and St.Louis' value will only go down.
In a keep-6 league, you want to win each year, but last year I had Lidstrom as a keeper and it hurts to "lose" a keeper spot on an aging player.

In a PTs only, keep 6, I'd trade Yandle for St.Louis and overload the offense to win now. Losing Yandle won't make a difference in a pts only league.

I'm sorry... but the homo-erotic overtone of the subject of this thread made me LOL

Now to answer your question... if he won't deal Getz for your "Yandle" straight up, then try for a 2 for 2 and go for Getz + St. Louis for Yandle + _______ depending on what his holes are.

Yandle and Price for Lundqvist and then keep Subban?

Give him Yandle for his first round draft pick and keep Subban,

id try this.

I like this move here.