trade offer schultz,heatley,,,,
 

long time i write here(lockout!!!:()

i have a offer on the table

i give

justin schultz and tj oshie

i receive

dany heatley and victor hedman

light upgrade for the forward but for the defense i think not

not bad but not great move , what your thinking about this....

At this point I'm not sure that Heatley should be considered an upgrade over Oshie and I'd take Schultz well over Hedman. I think you'd better stick with what you have

I wouldn't do that, nor do I understand the motivation for considering it.

This is not a good trade for you at all

I have to agree with the others. I wouldn't do it. I expect to see a bump in Heatleys numbers due to the Parise/Suter factor but he is on the decline. Oshie isnt anything spectactular but Schultz will be the one you will eventually regret giving up.

Stick with what you have here.

I would say to no to this trade. This trade does not make your team better.

Agree with the consensus here.

Heatley over Oshie is argueable. Heatley is on his way out...or at the very least...will remain a sub PPG player even with the new talent surrounding him. I'd expect Minn to try and bump up Granlund eventually to the #1 line which probably means Heatley is a 2nd liner in the next 2 years. Oshie has been steadily increasing his presence for St.L. I expect he will cement himself as the #1 Winger next to Backes for the forseeable future. So Oshie's upside already outweighs Heatley's expectations.

And Shultz is a far more valuable prospect (fantasy wise) than Hedman has ever been or ever projects to be.

Stick with what you have bud! Thank everyone above me who said the same.

I agree with no for this trade. I think Hedman will be fine in the long run, but I also think Schultz will be great too. Oshie vs Heatly, I give the edge to Oshie. No reason to make that deal.

I bought low on Hedman this summer because I haven't given up on him just yet, but I wouldn't trade Schultz for him. Plus I don't like heatley so I wouldn't do that deal if I was you.

thanks guy

when i am not sure about a move (or nearly sure thats a bad move)
i post it here and i have always good advice from you dobberdudes!!!

i dont have problem to trade schultz and oshie but what i am looking for are a good forward to put in my top 5 with kopi,parise,benn and max pac

the players i am looking in his roster is bobby ryan but he see him really big