Which side?
 

Standard cats, 16 team league.



Side A: Prince, Sandoval, Bourn

for

Side B: Teixeria, Zimmerman, BJ Upton


I'd be trading side B for side A. Is it a good deal?

I like side A better

I like side A better as well but totally depends on the cats.

Thanks guy the cats are -

Batting Average (AVG) Home Runs (HR)
Runs (R) Runs Batted In (RBI)
Stolen Bases (SB) On Base plus Slugging Pct (OPS)

Earned Run Average (ERA)* Strikeouts (K)
Walks plus Hits Per Innings Pitched (WHIP)* Wins (W)
Saves (SV) Holds (HD)


and that's Ryan Zimmerman.

I would definetly take side A on this.

Side A for me as well.

So it's side A for everyone, I thought it would be a little closer actually. The way I saw it was:

Prince > Teixeira
Sandoval < Zimmerman
Bourn < Upton

With side B getting the slight nod. Thanks for all the replies gents.

its more like Prince >>> Teix
3rd base pretty darn close
BJ is 1 of the least popular players that has decent HR & SB #'s every year. I could see Bourn being drafted very close 2 him in most leagues this year. I've seen 2 posts of early rankings and the last 2 sets of players are nearly side by side. Teix dropping off and Prince settling in as a fantasy stud in the AL really tips this trade to 1 side

Side A by a nice margin..

He also has Pedro Alvarez, would you swap out Panda for Alvarez?