Tatar vs Tangradi
 

Points only keeper, who'd you rather? Who is quicker to produce, if at all??

Thanks!

Tatar. He's putting it together this year, finally showing consistency from shift to shift. He's all over the ice.

Tatar for me as well.

Think there is room for Brunner, Nyqvist AND Tatar?? Cant see it unfortunately, but would love to be wrong here. Think he cracks the roster?

Not this year, no, but going forward? Definitely. And of those Brunner is the most likely to strike out.

Four years or so from now it's not entirely unlikely that we'll see a top six with Zetterberg, Filppula, Nyquist, Jarnkrok, Tatar and Brunner, although my money's on Jurco instead of Brunner.

within a year or two tatar should be getting decent minutes in detroit.

Tatar, easily.

Tatar wins easily here. Tangradi would be worth more if the league had PIM.

I'll take Tangradi because of size. Wouldn't want either, though.

I'm leaning towards Tangradi but its really close....Tangradi is a late bloomer IMO, I wouldn't write him off just yet.