Ranking goalies
 

How would you rank the following goalies in a keeper league? The cats are : W SO GAA SV%

Fleury
Halak
Miller
Ward

Thanks.

Miller
Fleury
Ward
Halak

For a keeper league this is very close between 2 pairs.

Halak- best ratios, wins will come up, SOs
Fluery


Miller
Ward

W-
Fleury
Ward
Miller
Halak

SO-
Halak
Ward
Miller
Fleury

GAA-
Halak
Miller
Fleury
Ward

SV%-
Halak
Ward
Miller
Fleury

Overall-
Ward
Miller
Fluery
Halak- (good stats but split crease hurts his value)

Do you think Elliott is the real deal? I don't. When Brian Elliott begins to play like Brian Elliot, Halak's starts and wins will increase.

miller
ward
fluery
halak

This is my ranking as well.

Halak gets knocked by Elliott (Elliott w/ Hitchcock that is).

I might bump Fleury up over Ward next year - but in hopes of a 2012-2013 season still, I think Fleury will get tons of rest with Vokoun in town, and I can't wait to see the new look Canes.

Miller
Ward
Fleury
Halak

Miller/Ward - pretty much next and neck over next 2 years, slight edge to Miller in a one-year, edge to Ward after 2 years..
Fleury
Halak

Like dyz but!......

Miller/Ward - pretty much next and neck over next 2 years, slight edge to Miller in a one-year, edge to Ward after 2 years..
Halak
Fleury - the only category Fleury might win over Halak is Ws. Halak will outperform Fleury in 3 of 4 cats. One could also make the argument that Vokoun is just as great of a threat to take starts from Fleury than Elliott is a threat to take starts from Halak. Just because they split starts last season doesn't mean it will happen again. I'm sure there will be a slight battle at the start, but I'm sure most people agree Halak will come out on top.