Top 10 keeper goalies in terms of value
 

Who are the top 10 keeper goalies in terms of value over the next 3 years?

W, GAA, SV%, SO

Top 10:
1. Henrik Lundqvist
2. Jonathan Quick
3. Pekka Rinne
4. Carey Price
5. Marc-Andre Fleury
6. Jaroslav Halak
7. Tukka Rask (I'm assuming Tim Thomas retires/takes a year off)
8. Mike Smith
9. Cory Schneider (I'm assuming Luongo is traded)
10. Roberto Luongo
------------------
11. Ryan Miller
12. Jimmy Howard
13. Jonas Hiller
14. Cam Ward
15. Anti Niemi
16. Ilya Bryzgalov
17. Mikka Kiprusoff
18. Kari Lehtonen
19. Andrej Pavelec
20. Nicklas Backstrom

Who are your top 10?

Top 10:
1. Henrik Lundqvist
2. Jonathan Quick
3. Pekka Rinne
4. Tukka Rask (I'm assuming Tim Thomas retires/takes a year off too)
5. Marc-Andre Fleury
6. Cory Schneider (I'm assuming Luongo is traded too)
7. Carey Price
8. Mike Smith
9. Jaroslav Halak
10. Roberto Luongo
------------------
11. Andrej Pavelec
12. Jimmy Howard
13. Ryan Miller
14. Cam Ward
15. Jonas Hiller
16. Ilya Bryzgalov
17. Mikka Kiprusoff
18. Kari Lehtonen
19. Anti Niemi
20. Nicklas Backstrom

1) Henrik Lundqvist
2) Pekka Rinne
3) Jonathan Quick
4) Ryan Miller
5) Carey Price
6) Cam Ward
7) Tuukka Rask
8) MA Fleury
9) Ilya Bryzgalov
10) Roberto Luongo

Top 10:
1. Henrik Lundqvist
2. Jonathan Quick
3. Pekka Rinne
4. Carey Price
4. Tuukka Rask
6. Marc-Andre Fleury
7. Mike Smith
8. Cory Schneider (assuming Luongo is traded)
9. Ryan Miller
10. Roberto Luongo (assuming Tampa or Toronto)
------------------
11. Jaroslav Halak
12. Kari Lehtonen
13. Jonas Hiller
14. Jimmy Howard
15. Ilya Bryzgalov
16. Cam Ward
17. Anti Niemi
18. Mikka Kiprusoff
19. Andrej Pavelec
20. Nicklas Backstrom

This is the list I would go with.

1. Lundqvist
2. Quick
3. Rinne
4. Price
5. Fleury
6. Schneider
7. Rask
8. Luongo
9. Miller
10. Bryzgalov

HM to Smith, Halak, Ward, Howard.

Henrik Lundqvist 165 2.15 .922 30 (very strong team)
Ilya Bryzgalov 153 2.35 .920 24 (settles in)
Tukka Rask (no Thomas) 152 2.18 .920 21
Jonathan Quick 148 2.25 .918 28 (must now show they can do it in Reg Season. Bernier strengthens)
Marc-Andre Fleury 143 2.35 .915 14 (Vokoun factor)
Anti Niemi 142 2.45 .916 15 (his job to lose. SJ stable or declining?)
Roberto Luongo (Vancouver) 141 2.35 .921 18
Cory Schneider (no Luongo) 140 2.45 .917 15
Jimmy Howard 139 2.27 .917 18 (no backup)
Pekka Rinne 138 2.48 .920 25 (rebuilding?, no backup)
Carey Price 138 2.42 .919 20 (Montreal isn't powerful)
Ryan Miller 137 2.50 .917 21 (average team)
Corey Crawford 136 2.60 .912 (how long does he hold the job? finally settles in?)
Kari Lehtonen 135 2.38 .921 20 (health could hurt numbers)
Michal Neuvirth 135 2.48 .915 15 (I think heir apparent)
Roberto Luongo (average team) 135 2.50 .920 16
Jonas Hiller 132 2.52 .917 12
Cam Ward 130 2.65 .916 15
Mikka Kiprusoff 126 2.40 .918 16 (Calgary falling?) (end is arriving)
Andrej Pavelec 125 2.75 .913 (Winnipeg rising or stable?)
Simeon Varlamov 124 2.63 .915 (must be relatively healthy)
Mike Smith 124 2.45 .915 15 (? strength of Phoenix) (can he maintain?)
Craig Anderson 122 2.77 .914 12 (Ottawa rising? stable? falling? good AHL tenders))
Martin Brodeur 120 2.45 .917 14 (divide by the number of seasons he plays)
Nicklas Backstrom 112 2.48 .917 14 (Minny rising?)
Jaroslav Halak 102 2.40 .916 18 (must become a #1)
Tuuka Rask (with Thomas) 90 2.20 .922 11
Brian Elliott 82 2.30 .918 16
Cory Schneider (with Luongo) 42 2.15 .920 8

Florida 148 2.42 .917 20 (Markstrom will soon arrive and team will rise)
Islanders 152 2.40 .915 16 (team rising, but with what tender?)
Edmonton 160 2.50 .915 12 (?Holtby or bring someone in?)
Columbus 125 2.85 .910 10 (what a mess)
Toronto 140 2.65 .914 11 (should start stabilizing)
Tampa 160 2.60 .911 10 (could be a surprise here)

Also, anyone who doesn't have Miller in their top 10 is crazy.

The guy hasn't posted a SV% south of .916 or a GAA north of 2.59 since the 07-08 season (averaging a SV% of .920, a GAA of 2.47, and 35 wins per season during that span).

I'm too lazy to look up every goalie in the league, but I'd be willing to make a blind wager that that puts him at least top 3 over the past 4 years and wouldn't be surprised if he was closer to #1 in that span.

1. Lundqvist
...
...
2. R.Miller
3. Bryz
4. Rinne
5. Quick
...
6. Rask
7. Fleury
8. Price

Howard/Luongo/Schneider probably fill out this group.
If the Wings get R.Suter, Howie is in my top 10.
The Vancouver goalie is also in my top 10.

1) Henrik Lundqvist
2) Pekka Rinne
3) Jonathan Quick
4) Ryan Miller
5) Carey Price
6) Corey Schnieder
7) Cam Ward
8) Tuukka Rask
9) MA Fleury
10) Roberto Luongo